21 Historic Hotels in the US That Look Stunning Online (But You’ll Regret Booking in 2026)

You will find most Americans make a booking after a quick glance at the fine lobby photography, never bothering with a review. These hotels are well aware of that tendency and plan accordingly.

Take the one at #1 on this list: for over $400 a night you get what some call an “luxury historic experience”, though guests would be more apt to call it a glorified haunted house with plumbing in keeping with the theme. Avoid parting with any money until you have gone through this entire list.

21. The Menger Hotel, San Antonio, Texas

Grand Victorian lobby of a historic Texas hotel with ornate chandeliers and antique furniture, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

The Menger is as old as they come, having been in operation since 1859 and still trading on its history. The pictures do not lie; there is dark wood and pressed tin overhead, a bar where Teddy Roosevelt was known to drink.

What you won’t see on the booking site is the reality of the original wing’s “historic” rooms, which come in at an average of 180 square feet.

The walls are paper thin, so much so that corridor conversations are audible from your room. As one reviewer put it (“I paid $280 a night to listen to a stranger’s phone calls all night,”): “Nice lobby, miserable sleep.”

20. Hotel del Coronado, Coronado, California

Iconic red-roofed Victorian beachfront hotel in Coronado California with ocean views, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

Then there is the Del, easily the most photographed hotel in the country and just as aggressively overpriced. An oceanview will set you back more than $500 per night. Given how vast the property is and the number of buildings involved, you could find yourself in a tower annex that bears no resemblance to the Victorian icon in the brochure.

“Make sure you know which building you are in before you book,” said one guest (“I booked the Del and ended up in what felt like a Marriott attached to a postcard,”).

19. Jekyll Island Club Resort, Jekyll Island, Georgia

Stately Victorian resort hotel with wide porches and Spanish moss draped oak trees in coastal Georgia, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

A true Gilded Age restoration, this retreat has all the hallmarks of a J.P. Morgan fantasy with its wide verandas and oaks and authentic 19th-century workmanship. The cost is commensurate with the illusion. You can expect to pay between $350 and $450 for a room in the historic club.

Yet those in the annex cottages will tell you the Wi-Fi is spotty, the fixtures are tired and housekeeping is hit or miss. The grounds are lovely enough, but the room itself is something of a lottery.

18. The Omni Mount Washington Resort, Bretton Woods, New Hampshire

Grand white mountain resort hotel with a dramatic view of Mount Washington in New Hampshire, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

Spectacular photos of a white castle set against the Presidential Range will have you convinced. In the flesh it is still quite something. But for the $400–$600 the nightly rate commands, guests find the historic rooms to be on the damp side and the heating unreliable when the season turns.

The dining is pricey even for a resort; one person recounted putting down $240 for two and leaving the table wanting more. The mountain view is no act. The value proposition is.

17. The Peabody Memphis, Memphis, Tennessee

Elegant grand hotel lobby in Memphis Tennessee with marble floors and ornate fountain, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

The Peabody has its charms, not least the twice-daily duck march. But for $300 and up a night, many say the rooms are dimly lit, outdated and carry a hint of must.

The ducks put on a show for the masses in the lobby, creating chaos and noise at 11am and 5pm on the dot. Should your room face the atrium, you will hear it all. It is a novelty, so book it as such or leave it alone.

16. The Historic Stafford’s Perry Hotel, Petoskey, Michigan

Classic early 20th century waterfront hotel in small town Michigan with harbor views and vintage signage, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

Petoskey is a charming town and the Perry Hotel’s waterfront spot is fine. But “historic” here translates to creaky floors and thin walls, not to mention bathrooms retrofitted in the 1990s and left at that.

During peak season you are looking at $250–$350 a night and would be forgiven for expecting more. Some have found the front desk to be dismissive of complaints. Save for the restaurant view, there is little to recommend the stay. The following is where most are taken aback.

15. The Hotel Bethlehem, Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

Restored arts and crafts style historic hotel in a Pennsylvania steel town with ornate brick facade, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

The Hotel Bethlehem is a fine example of restoration with impressive public areas and a building with real history. There is one catch, however. The rooms are small. The “standard king” in the historic wing is under 200 square feet.

For $220–$300 a night you have to sidestep to get past the foot of the bed. It might do for a brief stop, but don’t let the photos fool you into thinking it is a romantic getaway. > Read More: 19 US Small Towns That Are Quietly Disappearing (And What Happened to Them)

14. The Hermitage Hotel, Nashville, Tennessee

Beaux-Arts grand hotel lobby in Nashville Tennessee with marble columns and painted ceiling, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

You could call the Hermitage Nashville’s oldest and one of its finest hotels. It is also the epicenter for bachelorette party tourism. Being in the heart of downtown, the streets are anything but quiet on a Tuesday night, with the noise carrying on until 3am.

The rooms have an elegance that is truly historic, yet those on the lower floors will tell you they need earplugs to get any rest at $350–$500 a night, as “I spent $400 a night to hear a bachelorette group singing ‘Sweet Caroline’ at 2am,” put it in a review.

A gorgeous building, to be sure, but the location is something of a liability.

13. The Mission Inn Hotel, Riverside, California

Spanish colonial revival hotel in Riverside California with ornate towers and courtyard fountain, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

A true architectural marvel, the Mission Inn is a Spanish Mission Revival tangle of turrets, courtyards and covered arcades. The pictures don’t exaggerate the exterior. Inside the rooms is another matter altogether.

The labyrinthine nature of the place means some windows look out onto interior hallways or there is no natural light to be had. Despite the common areas being stunning, guests find the rooms cave-like and confining. For $250–$400 a night, the contrast between the website and where you actually sleep can be jarring.

12. The Grand Hotel, Mackinac Island, Michigan

Long white-porched Victorian resort hotel on Mackinac Island Michigan overlooking Lake Huron, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

The Grand Hotel has the world’s longest porch and will make you pay for the privilege. Rates begin at $500 per night and come with a mandatory dinner, want it or not.

It is a sizeable buffet with food that is little more than mediocre, running $95 a head and you have no choice but to cover it.

Then there is the island’s no-cars rule, which is all very charming until you are shelling out $20 each way for a horse-drawn carriage to go anywhere. In many ways, it is a beautiful spot that has mastered the art of monetizing nostalgia.

11. The Tabard Inn, Washington D.C.

Cozy Victorian rowhouse inn in Washington DC with exposed brick walls and antique decor, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

Then there is the Tabard Inn. Small and full of character, it photographs like a dream with its open fireplace, antiques and crooked hallways. But the photos don’t convey the din.

With the restaurant below packed on weekends and rowhouses right up against the walls, plus Dupont Circle foot traffic for the street-facing rooms, it is loud. Some of the rooms don’t even have a proper closet and “cozy” has to do a lot of work in what amounts to 150 square feet.

At $200–$280 a night in the District, there are better options. We nearly left this one off the list, but it would be remiss not to.

10. The Driskill Hotel, Austin, Texas

Ornate Romanesque revival hotel lobby in Austin Texas with longhorn steer heads and Victorian chandeliers, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

Austin’s most iconic address, the Driskill has a lobby that is quite the spectacle with its longhorn mounts, stained glass domes and a bar that has been hosting politicians and musicians since 1886.

The trouble is Austin’s rapid expansion has made the surrounding blocks a veritable wall of live music and bars. On 6th Street the hotel is sitting in the middle of an open-air nightclub on weekends.

You can hear the bass from the front rooms until 2am even with the windows shut. And while some quarters are well kept and feel of their time, others have not seen a proper renovation since the 1990s. Not worth the lottery at $300–$450 a night.

Read More: 17 US Hotel Chains That Aren’t Worth the Loyalty Points Anymore

9. The Stanley Hotel, Estes Park, Colorado

Iconic white Georgian revival hotel overlooking Rocky Mountain National Park in Colorado, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

The Stanley has its fame; it is the inspiration for The Shining and the ghost tour business is a legitimate operation here. The hotel is happy to lean on its haunted credentials if that is your thing.

The issue is the “haunted experience” will set you back $200–$350 for a room that is drafty and cold in the shoulder season and due for a bathroom overhaul.

Add to that the large, boisterous groups from the paranormal tours making their way through the corridors at ungodly hours, and as “I came for a romantic getaway and ended up sharing a hallway with 40 people in ghost-hunting gear,” wrote, you should know what you are paying for before you book.

8. The Inn at Little Washington, Washington, Virginia

Elegant country inn facade in a small Virginia village with lush garden and stone walls, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

You will find the rooms at Patrick O’Connell’s Inn at Little Washington to be beautifully done and the place is a true culinary landmark. The only letdown is the value proposition for those who have not read the fine print.

A weekend stay makes dinner at the restaurant de rigueur, at $300–$400 per person (not including wine). Tack on room rates of $450–$800 and a couple can easily put in $2,000 over two nights without having had a glass of wine.

It is an experience that lives up to its billing; most guests are simply unaware they have put down for a $3,000 weekend.

7. The Broadmoor, Colorado Springs, Colorado

Grand resort hotel complex reflected in a lake with Pikes Peak in the background in Colorado Springs, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

As a Forbes Five-Star, The Broadmoor is the real thing with magnificent grounds to match: three golf courses, a private lake and 185 acres. But it is also a huge conference resort for corporate types.

One might book it for an intimate historic getaway and then discover the lobby and restaurants are being run over by a 500-person business group. On top of room rates in excess of $400. there is a $75 nightly resort fee.

Some have observed that the staff’s attentiveness wanes when the hotel is at capacity for a conference. A fine property, but with a split personality.

6. The Greenbrier, White Sulphur Springs, West Virginia

Grand white neoclassical resort hotel in the West Virginia mountains with manicured grounds and American flags, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

The Greenbrier has all the hallmarks of one of America’s premier resort hotels, plus a Cold War nuclear bunker beneath it that is well worth a look.

Then there are the strictly enforced dress codes in the dining rooms (dinner calls for a jacket) and the mandatory $85 per night in resort fees. There is a feeling the place is torn between its history and an operating reality that does not quite measure up.

With rooms from $350 a night, many say the quality is not what you would get for the same money in another town. “”The bunker tour is worth $30. The room is not worth $430,”” as one visitor put it.

5. The Biltmore Estate Inn, Asheville, North Carolina

French Renaissance chateau style inn at Biltmore Estate in Asheville North Carolina surrounded by gardens, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

The marketing for the Biltmore Estate is hard to argue with and staying there seems like something out of a story. The Inn on Biltmore Estate is a modern structure built to fit in with the estate, though a good number of arrivals are surprised to learn it is not the mansion.

To get into the main Vanderbilt house you need a ticket of $75–$90 apiece, which is extra on top of the $350–$550 room rate.

“I paid $400 a night to stay near the house, not in it,” was the view of one guest. Best to check the details before you start picturing yourself in a Vanderbilt bedroom.

4. The Fairmont San Francisco, San Francisco, California

Imposing Beaux-Arts hotel on Nob Hill in San Francisco with city views at dusk, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

Perched on Nob Hill, the Fairmont is at one of San Francisco’s finest addresses with architecture to show for it: marble floors, high ceilings and an air of occasion. In 2026 the picture is more complicated.

The area around the hotel has gone to seed and some do not feel safe making their way to a restaurant after dark.

For the $450–$700 they are asking for a room in the old tower, you see your money’s worth in the lobby, but the rest of the hotel is past its prime. Recent reviews cite 10–15 minute waits for the elevator and subpar housekeeping. Not worth $600 a night.

3. The Plaza Hotel, New York City, New York

Iconic limestone and terracotta hotel on Central Park South in New York City at twilight, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

The Most Disappointing Icon of Them All

People come to The Plaza with high expectations given its global fame. The hotel has had its share of upheaval, from various owners to a condo conversion that has taken a large part of the building. The renovations since have been described by some as anything but even.

You can get a standard room for as little as $700 per night, though the most economical of these are small and face the city; they bear no resemblance to the Grand Park View suites you see in the marketing. Opinions on the service are equally divided. While some will tell you the staff is wonderfully attentive, others have had to put up with 45 minute waits for room service and front desk personnel who appear to be at their wits’ end.

“I’ve stayed in the Plaza twice,” is how one veteran guest put it. “The first time was magical. The second time I understood why the first time felt special – it was a fluke.” When entry-level rooms come in at $700–$1,200 a night, it is a high stakes gamble. Bad – but nothing compared to what’s waiting at #1.

2. The Wentworth by the Sea, New Castle, New Hampshire

Grand white Victorian seaside hotel on a rocky New Hampshire coastline overlooking the Atlantic Ocean, warm editorial travel photography, golden hour, photorealistic, no text, no watermark, 16:9
Image for illustration purpose only.

Then there is The Wentworth by the Sea. As one of the grand hotels of New England, it is well photographed for good reason: a white Victorian that gleams from its rocky tidal island, hemmed in by water on three sides.

It is an extraordinary sight and the rates reflect that, with summer peaks of $350–$600 a night. In practice, however, the property has been at odds with maintenance ever since its 2003 restoration. One finds salt air corrosion on the windows, erratic air conditioning in the older wing and a spa that is understaffed for the size of the place.

The location is lovely enough, but a summer visitor shelling out $500 may find the pool deck crowded with Marriott rewards members, spoiling the boutique atmosphere the brochures tout. Some say the hotel’s finest attribute is best viewed from the public park across the street.

1. The Omni Homestead Resort, Hot Springs, Virginia

The Most Regretted Splurge in American Hotel History

Let me give you the real #1. There is a particular kind of trap that historic hotels have made an art of, the so-called “iconic photo” booking, and it has nothing to do with noise or poor rooms. The title of most-regretted US historic hotel goes to The Omni Homestead Resort in Hot Springs, Virginia. It has been around since 1766 and the imagery is hard to argue with: a stately red-brick Georgian tower coming out of the Alleghenies, formal gardens and porticos with white columns. You will find it on every “America’s best historic hotels” list.

But those lists leave things out. For $450–$700 a night, a good many guests consider the rooms to be among the more let-downs in American hospitality. Those in the main building are tiny and old-fashioned, and there are reports of maintenance problems left unresolved by management. On top of the $60 resort fee, you are practically obliged to eat here; the town is 35 minutes off and offers little else, yet the food does not justify the cost. A retired travel writer from Virginia put it this way: “I’ve stayed at every major grand resort hotel in the eastern United States.

The Homestead is the only one where I left wishing I hadn’t gone at all. The building is magnificent. Everything behind the facade is a disappointment.” With all-in costs of $500–$760 including the fees and meals, one is left with a sense of being done over that a cheaper disappointment would not elicit. No other hotel in the country has set its expectations so high only to have the execution fall short. The photos are genuine. The experience is not. Now you know why we put this one last.


Some Historic Hotels Really Are Worth It – Know Which Ones Before You Book

To be clear, historic hotels are not to be avoided. The Hay-Adams in D.C., Denver’s Brown Palace or Monterey’s Hotel del Monte are worth the asking price.

It is a matter of details that don’t show in a picture: whether the place is properly maintained or simply well marketed, the noise levels, the size of the room. Forward this to any friend making a “treat yourself” reservation; their credit card will be grateful.

Lachlan Taylor

Lachlan Taylor

Lachlan aka Lockie is a contributing writer at Humble Trail, known for his down-to-earth style and passion for the great outdoors. Born and raised in the small town of Deloriane, Tasmania, Lockie developed a deep love for nature and adventure from a young age. His articles are a blend of his personal adventures and insightful explorations, often focused on sustainable travel, wilderness treks, and the serene beauty of untouched landscapes. Always with his own reusable coffee cup in hand, Lockie loves a good caffeine fix as much as everyone else on the Humble Trail team.

View Lachlan’s Muck Rack profile.

The Greenbrier resort in White Sulphur Springs, West Virginia
Previous Story

Historic Hotels That Go All Out for Christmas, Ranked From Worth the Splurge to Overrated

Next Story

25 Historic Hotels in the US That Are Absolutely Worth Every Extra Dollar in 2026